Insurance

Pacific Blue Cross: Paid Search Restructure Doubles Conversion Rate and Halves CPA

A full paid media audit, rebuilt conversion tracking and a business-unit campaign architecture nearly doubled conversion rate, cut CPA by close to half and scaled monthly conversions from under 1,800 to over 3,800 for BC's leading health, dental and travel benefits provider.

~100% Increase in paid search conversion rate
~50% Reduction in cost per acquisition (CPA)
3,800+ Monthly conversions, up from under 1,800
4 Business units on dynamic budget allocation
Background Client — Pacific Blue Cross

Pacific Blue Cross is British Columbia's leading health, dental and travel benefits provider, safeguarding health and well-being across the province for over eight decades. Providing coverage for individuals, families and organizations, it manages a comprehensive suite of products spanning travel insurance, personal health plans, small business group benefits and retirement solutions.

Pacific Blue Cross had managed its paid search operations in-house for several years. While paid search provided an established baseline of presence, the accounts had entered a period of stagnant growth.

Without granular attribution across its diverse product lines, the brand found it challenging to scale performance efficiently or defend market share against aggressive regional and national insurance competitors.

Solution

What we did

  • Paid Search
  • Conversion Tracking Architecture
  • Data & Analytics

Binary & Co was engaged to conduct a comprehensive overhaul of Pacific Blue Cross's paid media presence, rebuilding its Google Ads and Microsoft Advertising accounts around clean data, high-intent structure and flexible budgets.

01

Exhaustive paid media audit

We began the engagement with an exhaustive audit across Pacific Blue Cross's Google Ads and Microsoft Advertising accounts.

The audit uncovered significant ad spend wastage driven by internal keyword competition, redundant ad copy variations and fragmented landing page experiences that diluted intent.

02

Conversion tracking architecture & real-time dashboards

To establish full visibility and control, we re-architected the entire conversion tracking framework.

By integrating these streamlined data streams into custom, real-time Looker Studio dashboards, Pacific Blue Cross gained immediate clarity into keyword-level efficiency, cost-per-conversion dynamics and cross-channel revenue contributions.

03

Business-unit campaign silos & competitor conquesting

With clean attribution in place, we restructured the paid search accounts into dedicated, high-intent campaign silos aligned to Pacific Blue Cross's distinct business units:

  • Travel Insurance
  • Personal Health Insurance
  • Small Business Benefits
  • Retirement Coverage

We paired this clean architecture with an aggressive competitor conquesting strategy targeting major rival brands, allowing Pacific Blue Cross to capture prospective policyholders actively evaluating competing alternatives in British Columbia.

04

Dynamic, multi-unit budget optimization

The modular account structure unlocked dynamic budget optimization. Rather than deploying static monthly budgets, we reallocated spend in real time toward the business units demonstrating the highest return and market demand.

This meant shifting resources fluidly between high-volume travel periods and peak individual health enrollment cycles.

Results

The results.

01 ~100%

Conversion rate nearly doubled: Within the first year of optimization, conversion rate climbed from baseline levels below 3% to sustained rates above 5.5%, peaking at over 9% in targeted campaign flights.

02 ~50%

Substantial CPA reduction: Overall account CPA dropped by close to 50%, falling from historical highs above $10 to under $4 across Google Ads campaigns and enabling significantly higher lead volume within disciplined monthly budgets.

03 3,800+

Surging conversion volumes: Monthly conversions scaled from under 1,800 to over 3,800, including online policy payments, quote completions, broker inquiries and app downloads.

04 4

Multi-unit efficiency: Leadership can now deploy budgets across four business units based on profitability and seasonal demand, turning paid search into an agile engine across travel, health, dental and small business lines.

Targeted competitor search campaigns also generated immediate incremental policy acquisition across travel and health insurance. Together, the restructure and tracking enhancements transformed Pacific Blue Cross's paid search from an operational baseline into a scalable acquisition and retention engine across all key business divisions.

Next

Tell us your story

✓ 01✓ 02✓ 03✓ 04
Delivered
05 — Up next

Get in touch to work with an agency that aims to understand your business and customers as well as you do.

Your next high-value buyer is already out there.

Spend 30 minutes with our growth team to review your current funnel. We will highlight key bottleneck areas and give you 4 to 5 practical steps to improve your lead qualification and drive higher conversion rates.

Book a chat